2007 Edition

Laureates

María Guadalupe

Graduate School of Business Columbia University

Vicente Cuñat Martínez

Departament of Economy and Business

Winning paper

Summary of the winning paper of the II Edition of the “Jaime Fernández de Araoz on Corporate Finance” Award

LOBALISATION AND THE PROVISION OF INCENTIVES WITHIN THE COMPANY: THE EFFECT OF INTERNATIONAL COMPETITION

The winning project is an empirical study of how companies adjust their executive salary policies to match the competitive environment in which they operate. To carry out the study, the authors used detailed information on North American companies and executives covering a period of time when fluctuating exchange rates and business policy obliged many companies to adapt to a changing environment.

The results of the study show that companies facing an unexpected increase in levels of international competition make significant changes to the remuneration structure for their executives. The main changes observed are as follows: instead of earning a fixed salary, remuneration becomes more directly linked to company performance, so that a greater proportion of salary is linked to results; likewise, salary increases associated with promotion are larger and this leads to a greater disparity of salaries within the company; furthermore, companies give greater rewards to executive talent and have a more aggressive personnel policy. In general terms, the results show how more intense international competition makes company profits more sensitive to good or bad decisions made by employees, the reaction of companies to this phenomena being to demand greater effort and skills from their staff and to reward them accordingly.

The results indicate that internationalisation, deregulation and increased competition between modern economies are partly responsible for labour mobility, changes in salary structures and particularly the increase in the use of incentive packages such as productivity bonuses or “stock options”.

The work sits within the framework of a wider line of research developed by the authors studying the effect of competition on diverse areas of company organisation, which shows that these results can be extended to other countries, to competition between local companies and to the body of workers within the company. The project in relevant insofar as it sheds light on the mechanisms through which globalisation and competition affect company productivity and employee welfare.

If you would like to read the complete work, you can click here:

The jury

Jury of the II Edition of the “Jaime Fernández de Araoz Corporate Finance” Award

Members of the Jury of the 2007 Edition of the “Jaime Fernández de Araoz Corporate Finance” Award comprises the following individuals:

CHAIRMAN:

  • D. Juan Rodríguez Inciarte

General Director of Grupo SANTANDER

VICE-CHAIRMAN:

  • D. Alberto Ibáñez González

Chairman of CITIGROUP España

SECRETARY:

  • Elena López-Henares y Sancho, Director of Knowledge Management of ARAOZ Y RUEDA ABOGADOS

Members

  • Fernando Abril-Martorell Hernández, Managing Director of CREDIT SUISSE GROUP
  • Claudio Aguirre Pemán, Chairman of ALTAMAR CAPITAL PRIVADO S.G.E.C.R.S.A.
  • Diego del Alcázar Silvela, Chairman of INSTITUTO DE EMPRESA
  • Ignacio Álvarez Rendueles, Managing Director of GOLDMAN SACHS
  • Nicolás Baselga Canthal, Vice-president of MORGAN STANLEY
  • Claudio Boada Palleres, Chairman of CIRCULO DE EMPRESARIOS
  • Arturo Bris, Professor at YALE SCHOOL OF MANAGEMENT AND CORPORATE GOVERNANCE INSTITUTE
  • José Manuel Campa Fernández, Professor in Financial Management at IESE
  • Álvaro Cuervo García, Professor in Business Economics at the UNIVERSIDAD COMPLUTENSE DE MADRID
  • Guillermo de la Dehesa Romero, Chairman of AVIVA and Vice Chairman of GOLDMAN SACHS EUROPE
  • Juan Entrecanales Franco, Chairman of ACCIONA INFRAESTRUCTURA and Vice-Chairman of ACCIONA
  • Oscar Fanjul Martín, Vice-chairman of OMEGA CAPITAL
  • Alejandro Fernández de Araoz Gómez-Acebo, Founding partner of ARAOZ Y RUEDA ABOGADOS
  • Álvaro Fernández de Araoz Gómez-Acebo, Director of Products and Services of TERRA
  • Carlos Fernández de Araoz Gómez-Acebo, Partner-Director of MONITOR GROUP HISPANIA
  • Santiago Fernández Valbuena, Chairman of FONDITEL and General Director of Finance and Resources of TELEFÓNICA
  • Luis de Guindos, Chairman of LEHMAN BROTHERS
  • Javier Loizaga Jiménez, Managing Director of MERCAPITAL
  • Pedro López-Quesada, Managing Director of Corporate Banking of CITIGROUP
  • José Luis Madariaga, Chairman of PRICEWATERHOUSECOOPERS
  • Petra Mateos, Chairman of HISPASAT
  • Aldo Olcese Santonja, Chairman of the Advisory Borrad of Société Générale
  • Felipe Oriol Diaz-Bustamante, Chairman of CORPFIN CAPITAL
  • Rafael del Pino, Chairman of FERROVIAL
  • Rafael Repullo, Director of the CENTRO DE ESTUDIOS MONETARIOS Y FINANCIEROS
  • Miquel Roca Junyent, Founding partner of ROCA JUNYENT ABOGADOS
  • Luisa Sáenz de Fernández de Araoz
  • Javier Sagi-Vela González, Director General of UNIVERSIA
  • Eduardo Serra Rexach, Chairman of EDUARDO SERRA Y ASOCIADOS
  • Jorge Villavechia Barnach-Calbó, Director General of Grupo DAMM
  • Fernando Abril-Martorell Hernández, Managing Director of CREDIT SUISSE GROUP
  • Claudio Aguirre Pemán, Chairman of ALTAMAR CAPITAL PRIVADO S.G.E.C.R.S.A.
  • Diego del Alcázar Silvela, Chairman of INSTITUTO DE EMPRESA
  • Ignacio Álvarez Rendueles, Managing Director of GOLDMAN SACHS
  • Nicolás Baselga Canthal, Vice-president of MORGAN STANLEY
  • Claudio Boada Palleres, Chairman of CIRCULO DE EMPRESARIOS
  • Arturo Bris, Professor at YALE SCHOOL OF MANAGEMENT AND CORPORATE GOVERNANCE INSTITUTE
  • José Manuel Campa Fernández, Professor in Financial Management at IESE
  • Álvaro Cuervo García, Professor in Business Economics at the UNIVERSIDAD COMPLUTENSE DE MADRID
  • Guillermo de la Dehesa Romero, Chairman of AVIVA and Vice Chairman of GOLDMAN SACHS EUROPE
  • Juan Entrecanales Franco, Chairman of ACCIONA INFRAESTRUCTURA and Vice-Chairman of ACCIONA
  • Oscar Fanjul Martín, Vice-chairman of OMEGA CAPITAL
  • Alejandro Fernández de Araoz Gómez-Acebo, Founding partner of ARAOZ Y RUEDA ABOGADOS
  • Álvaro Fernández de Araoz Gómez-Acebo, Director of Products and Services of TERRA
  • Carlos Fernández de Araoz Gómez-Acebo, Partner-Director of MONITOR GROUP HISPANIA
  • Santiago Fernández Valbuena, Chairman of FONDITEL and General Director of Finance and Resources of TELEFÓNICA
  • Luis de Guindos, Chairman of LEHMAN BROTHERS
  • Javier Loizaga Jiménez, Managing Director of MERCAPITAL
  • Pedro López-Quesada, Managing Director of Corporate Banking of CITIGROUP
  • José Luis Madariaga, Chairman of PRICEWATERHOUSECOOPERS
  • Petra Mateos, Chairman of HISPASAT
  • Aldo Olcese Santonja, Chairman of the Advisory Borrad of Société Générale
  • Felipe Oriol Diaz-Bustamante, Chairman of CORPFIN CAPITAL
  • Rafael del Pino, Chairman of FERROVIAL
  • Rafael Repullo, Director of the CENTRO DE ESTUDIOS MONETARIOS Y FINANCIEROS
  • Miquel Roca Junyent, Founding partner of ROCA JUNYENT ABOGADOS
  • Luisa Sáenz de Fernández de Araoz
  • Javier Sagi-Vela González, Director General of UNIVERSIA
  • Eduardo Serra Rexach, Chairman of EDUARDO SERRA Y ASOCIADOS
  • Jorge Villavechia Barnach-Calbó, Director General of Grupo DAMM

Award ceremony

 Award Ceremony for the II Edition of the “Jaime Fernández de Araoz Corporate Finance” Award

Premios_Jfa_entrega2007_aguirre HRH The Prince of Asturias at his arrival to the
II Edition of the “Jaime Fernandez de Araoz Corporate Finance” Award Ceremony being received by the President of the Community of Madrid , HE Ms. Esperanza Aguirre.
Premios_Jfa_entrega2007_saludo_presidente_jurado HRH The Prince of Asturias at his arrival to the
II Edition of the “Jaime Fernandez de Araoz Corporate Finance” Award Ceremony, being received by the President of the Jury, Mr. Juan Rodríguez Inciarte, General Director of Grupo SANTANDER and by the State Secretary for Economic Affaires and Finance HE Mr. David Vegara.
Premios_Jfa_jurado_2007_principe HRH The Prince of Asturias with the members of the Jury of the II Edition of the
“Jaime Fernández de Araoz Corporate Finance” Award.
Premios_Jfa_entrega2007_viuda HRH The Prince of Asturias with Luisa Saénz Varona, Jaime Fernández de Araoz’s widow and her children.
Premios_Jfa_entrega2007_discurso_principe HRH The Prince of Asturias during his speech delivered at the Award Ceremony of the II Edition of the “Jaime Fernandez de Araoz Corporate Finance” Award.
(see speech transcription)
Premios_Jfa_2007_entrega4 Speech delivered by Mr. Alejandro Fernández de Araoz Gómez-Acebo at the Award Ceremony of the II Edición of the
“Jaime Fernández de Araoz Corporate Finance” Award.
(see speech transcription)
Premios_Jfa_2007_aguirre Speech delivered by the President of the Madrid Community HE Ms. Esperanza Aguirre at the Award Ceremony of the II Edición of the
“Jaime Fernández de Araoz Corporate Finance” Award.

(see speech transcription)
Premios_Jfa_2007_vegara Speech delivered by HE the Secretary of the State for the Economy Mr. David Vegara at the Award Ceremony of the II Edición of the
“Jaime Fernández de Araoz Corporate Finance” Award.

(see speech transcription)
Premios_Jfa_entrega2007_mesa_presidencial Presidential table of the Award Ceremony of the
II Edition of the “Jaime Fernández de Araoz Corporate Finance” Award. Left to wright: Chairman of the Jury, Mr. Juan Rodríguez Inciarte, General Director of Grupo SANTANDER, the President of the Madrid Community, HE Ms. Esperanza AguirreHRH the Prince of Asturias, the Secretary of the State for the Economy HE Mr. David Vergara, and the Vice-chairman of the Jury, Mr. Alberto Ibañez, Chairman of CITIGROUP España.
Premios_Jfa_entrega2007_premiados1 HRH The Prince of Asturias presenting the Award to the winners María Guadalupe and Vicente Cuñat.
Premios_Jfa_entrega2007_discurso_premiados The winners María Guadalupe and Vicente Cuñat during their acceptance speech.
Premios_Jfa_entrega2007_premiados_principe HRH The Prince of Asturias with the award winners, María Guadalupe and Vicente Cuñat.
Premios_Jfa_entrega2007_fin_ceremonia HRH the Prince of Asturias after the Award Ceremony with the President of the Madrid Community, HE Ms. Esperanza Aguirre, the Secretary of the State for the Economy, HE Mr. David Vergara, the Chairman of the Jury, Mr. Juan Rodríguez Inciarte, General Director of Grupo Santander, Luisa Saénz Varona,
Jaime Fernández de Araoz’s widow, and the winners,
María Guadalupe and Vicente Cuñat.

Gallery

Sponsors